The tax treatment of Libra: old wine in new barrels?

The tax treatment of Libra: old wine in new barrels? 1

What is the Libra cryptocurrency?

Libra is a cryptocurrency which, like other cryptocurrencies, is based on a blockchain technology which is limited to the participants (“permissioned blockchain”). Susanne has already described the structure of the Libra cryptocurrency.

As a so-called stablecoin Libra is tied to a basket of currencies. For hedging purposes, investments are made in various currencies with banks as well as government bonds purchased. Libra is obtained through payment in a fiat currency. Just like other cryptocurrencies, Libra is held on a private key and exchanged again into other cryptocurrencies or fiat currencies via exchanges.

In my opinion, Libra’s structure does not differ significantly from other cryptocurrencies for the purposes of German income tax. Therefore, the purchase and sale of Libra as part of private assets within the one-year speculation period is subject to German income tax (Section 23 para. 1 no. 2 of the German Income Tax Act, EStG). If Libra is held as part of a business, any profits and losses related thereto do not only affect the company’s income tax or corporation tax, but also its trade tax. The fact that Libra is based on fiat currencies has no influence on the tax treatment, in my opinion. With respect to the other important points on the tax treatment of any profits related to cryptocurrencies, I can therefore refer to my earlier contributions in the series Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies (1+2+6).However, if Libra is exchanged into currencies other than the Euro, a taxable profit or loss will also arise within the one-year speculation period. At the same time, it should be noted that a new one-year speculation period starts for the currency the Libra is exchanged for. It is important to look into whether or not your bank informs you of the taxable currency gains. If not, you need to calculate the speculative gains yourself and declare them on your income tax return in order to avoid any consequences  under criminal law (see Part 5 of my series “Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies” on the topic of the exchange of information).

Value added tax and inheritance tax in Germany

From a value added tax perspective, Libra also does not present any significant differences compared to Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. Therefore, Libra would also have to fall under the value added tax exemption of currencies (see my contributions Part 3+4 from the series Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies). The German gifting or inheritance of Libra is subject to inheritance tax just like the other cryptocurrencies (see my contribution on the topic of gift tax and co. from the series “Bitcoin and co.”). It is important to note that Libra are lost if the private key is lost. Therefore, in the case of gifts or inheritance, the access data must be known to the donee or the heir.

For Libra, the same tax-related questions arise as for other cryptocurrencies, e.g. the exchange of information, can I “import” Libra from abroad without limitation as well as possible consequences under German criminal law if the tax declaration obligations are not met? Since Libra, like other cryptocurrencies, is based on blockchain technology, Libra will also be classed as intangible assets on the balance sheet (see my article on Bitcoin on the balance sheet).

 



By continuing, you accept our privacy policy.
You May Also Like
Neues Buch: Das Recht der digitalen Zahlungsdienstleistungen
Read More

PayTechLaw – now available as a book!

With the title “PayTechLaw – The Law of Digital Payment Services”, a new handbook has been published by C.H. BECK. It is dedicated entirely to the regulatory and civil law framework of digital payments. The editors: Prof. Dr. Carsten Herresthal, LL.M., and Annerton partners Dr. Matthäus Schindele and Frank Müller, LL.M. – all recognized experts in payment services and financial regulatory law. They were supported by a top-class team of authors – including many familiar names from the Annerton environment and beyond.
Read More
VAT Treatment of Trading in Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) 3
Read More

VAT Treatment of Trading in Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs)

So far, there is no supreme court ruling or official administrative guidance on the VAT treatment of NFTs. A recent case before the Lower Saxony Tax Court involves a domestic entrepreneur who traded NFT “collectibles” via the OpenSea platform in 2021. The digital works themselves were not sold; instead, blockchain-based database entries were transferred. The sales were executed automatically via smart contracts, which are not considered legal contracts.
Read More